Tuesday, March 31, 2015

HOW IT WAS: The Lord’s Supper as Jesus Inaugurated It. (Part #2)

"Now on the first day of the Feast of the Unleavened Bread the disciples came to Jesus, saying to him, 'Where do you want us to prepare for you to eat the Passover?' And he said, 'Go into the city to a certain man, and say to him, "The Teacher says, 'My time is at hand; I will keep the Passover at your house with my disciples'"'" (Mat 26:17, 18).

We can assume that in Mark’s family’s house all was cleansed of leaven and ready for the Passover holiday, as was befitting of Jews. At sundown, Jesus and his twelve closest disciples had gathered in the upper room of the house. It was time for the Passover meal.


Contrary to what Leonardo Da Vinci painted a millennium and a half after Jesus Christ, the custom was for 1st century Jews to recline at the Passover. That means that they each lay down at a low table. All four Gospels, written in Greek, clearly indicate in their original language that Jesus and his disciples were “reclining” (Mat 26:20; Mar 14:18; Luk 22:14; Joh 13:23). Not sitting.[1]

This explains how, according to John’s Gospel, “[the disciple] whom Jesus loved” (John?) could have been “leaning back on Jesus’ chest” (Joh 13:23-25).

The table, either woven mats on the floor or, more often in wealthy houses, a special low structure called a triclinium, was arranged in three parts and participants at the meal, lay down on pillows.[2] They supported themselves on their left elbows while their right hands remained free for use while eating.[3]

At the opening moment in the Passover ceremony, it is recorded that Jesus had these words to say:

“With fervent desire I have desired to eat this Passover with you before I suffer; for I say to you, I will no longer eat of it until it is fulfilled in the kingdom of God” (Luk 22:15, 16).

After the customary opening blessing over the first cup of wine[4], Jesus said:

“Take this and divide it among yourselves …” (Luk 22:17).

At this stage in the Passover liturgy, the designated leader would wash his hands. In this case Rabbi Jesus was the leader. After the leader washed his hands, all the others at the table would wash their hands.[5]

It appears, however, that at this point in the meal there began a small argument between some of the disciples. They argued over who would be greater in rank once Jesus established his Messianic kingdom.[6] Such arguments had happened before.[7] Regardless, Jesus took this moment in the Passover ceremony to instruct his followers on the nature of true greatness:

"And supper being ended … Jesus … rose from supper and laid aside his garments, took a towel and girded himself. After that, he poured water into a basin and began to wash the disciples’ feet, and to wipe them with the towel with which he was girded (Joh 13:2-5).

In a standard 1st century Passover, after the ceremonial hand washing, the dishes of symbolic food would be brought into the dining area. The leader would then take a small sprig of the bitter herbs, pronounce the blessing, then dip it into a bowl of salt water, and eat it whole. Afterwards, he would hand a sprig of bitter herbs to each person present.

They would likewise dip theirs in salt water, and then eat it. Immediately after this action, the dishes of food were removed from the dining area. The dishes were apparently removed to arouse curiosity and anticipation for what was to follow. Right after the removal of the dishes, the second cup of wine was filled and the blessing pronounced.

However, no one drank yet.

Then the youngest male in the group[8], often a son of the leader, would stand up and chant in the Hebrew language a series of four questions. [9] At the Last Supper it probably was John who asked the questions, since it seems that he was the youngest of Jesus’ twelve disciples. The questions provided the leader with the opportunity to explain the symbolic food items that would soon be returned to the table. This naturally led into his telling the biblical story about God’s deliverance of the Israelites from Egyptian bondage.

Once the questions were asked, the dishes were returned to the table and the leader began his answer. He would relate Israel’s history, from Terah, the father of Abraham, to the exodus from Egypt and the giving of the Law. The Law of Moses—or as it is called in Hebrew, the Torah—mandated that the annual Passover meal include the following food items:[10]

1. Roasted lamb …
-- called ha-Pesakh, which means “the Passover.” In Jesus’ day it was sometimes called ha-guf, “the body.”[11] The leader would explain that it was to remind the meal’s participants of their ancestors’ deliverance. The Angel of Death “passed over” those houses which were properly marked on their door frames with lamb’s blood—a lamb that had been slain by a family representative, then entirely eaten by a minimum group of 10 people. When the Angel saw the blood on the doorposts,[12] … and only then, he refrained from killing the firstborn of that household.

2. Unleavened bread …
-- (Heb. matzah)—It was bread made without yeast, because God’s deliverance would arrive so swiftly that there wasn’t time to let the dough rise before baking it.[13]

3. Bitter herbs …
-- (Heb. maror)—Bitter vegetables[14] of most any local sort that would remind the Jewish people of the bitterness their ancestors endured as slaves in Egypt.

According to ancient religious writings of the times,[15] Jews almost universally included the following items as well:

1. A bowl of salt water on the table to symbolize the tears their ancestors shed while in bondage.

2. A fruit puree called kharoset that was designed to remind the participants of the clay and mortar used while the ancient Hebrews made and lay bricks as slaves in Egypt.

3. One cup for each participant that was filled four times throughout the meal with red wine. And emptied four times.[16] The wine symbolized the joy of the occasion. Each cup contained one part real wine mixed with three parts water. The wine was diluted to ensure that all participants, particularly the children, did not become drunk or fall asleep during the Passover meal.[17]
It was the duty of the leader of the meal to explain what each item on the table meant and to tell his group the story of the exodus from Egypt. We can only assume that Jesus did so, being a Torah-observant Jew.[18] The Gospels do not elaborate on this. They have a narrower focus.

End Notes

[1] TEV mistakenly has “sat down” etc. which is not only a bad rendering of the Greek (anekeito), but also displays the translators’ lack of background cultural knowledge. By understanding that at feasts free 1st century Jews reclined, we can better see how certain events transpired, such as the crying woman who anointed Jesus’ feet with perfume while he was reclining at the home of Simon the Pharisee (Luk. 7:36-50). And others (E.g. Luk. 11:37ff; Joh. 12:1-3).
[2] Or little “couches” made from cushions.
[3] The left hand then, as is the case in India and in some Arab countries today, was used by its owner during “bathroom” duties. Hand + water. Thus it was considered unsanitary to use for general handling of food. See Keener, Craig S. The IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament. Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 1993, p. 298.
[4] Called the Cup of Sanctification because, from its consumption on, the Passover meal is officially begun.
[5] This ancient practice differs slightly from modern Passover customs where usually only the table leader ritually washes his/her hands.
[6] From Luke’s narrative (22:24-27), we see that the argument between disciples continued even after the inauguration of the Lord’s Table. Or possibly John’s account describes Jesus’ premonition that such an argument would take place. Either way, it happened.
[7] Mar 10:35-44.
[8] Provided he were old enough to carry out the duty. Otherwise, the father/leader or someone else would do it for him.
[9] The 4 Questions of Jesus’ time were only slightly different than those in the modern seder. They are: 1) “What distinguishes this night from all other nights? ... for on all other nights we eat leavened or unleavened bread, but [why] on this night do we only eat unleavened bread?” 2) “On all other nights we eat any kind of herbs, but [why] on this night only bitter herbs?” 3) “On all other nights we eat meat roasted, stewed, or boiled, but [why] on this night only roasted?” 4) “On all other nights we dip (the herbs) only once, but on this night twice?” (Mishnah, Pesakhim [Passovers] 10.4). Since in modern times Jews do not eat the sacrificed lamb because the temple was destroyed in A.D. 70, question #3 has been replaced with #4, and the new fourth question inquires why they recline to dine on this special night, while sitting on other nights.
[10] Exo 12:8.
[11] E.g. “While the Sanctuary stood, they brought before him his body [Heb. GUFO] of the Passover.” (Mishnah, Pesakhim [Passovers] 10.3, emphasis mine). After the temple’s destruction, the matzah came to represent the Passover lamb. Interestingly enough, Jesus referred to the unleavened bread of the Eucharist as “my body” (Luk. 22:19; 1Cor. 11:24). Justin Martyr (c. A.D. 135), a Christian Samaritan, wrote that the lamb was roasted in the form of a cross; one spit, he says, went through from the lower parts to the head, and again another across the shoulders, to which the front legs of the lamb were fastened and hung; and so was in every way a type of Christ on the cross. (Dialogue With Trypho the Jew, chp 40). Modern Jews, being forbidden to sacrifice the lamb anywhere else but the temple, simply provide a lamb shank bone, or sometimes even a chicken leg, as a temporary substitute.
[12] Exo 12:7. Is it mere coincidence that the path of the blood, applied by a hyssop flower, starting horizontally from one side frame to the next, then vertically from the basin on the ground upward to the overhead door frame, … is it mere coincidence that the blood formed the sign of a cross?
[13] Deu 16:3.
[14] Exo. 12:8. The Vulgate Latin version translated by St. Jerome, who lived in Bethlehem, renders it "wild lettuces." The Targum of Yonathan, an early Aramaic free-translation has: "with horehound and endive they shall eat it."
[15] Mishnah, Pesakhim (Passovers) 10.15. See synopsis by Stein. “Last Supper” in DJG, p. 446.
[16] The first cup is called “the cup of Sanctification” - “I will bring you out.”
The second cup is called “the cup of Thanksgiving” - “I will rid you out of their bondage.”
The third cup is called “the cup of Redemption” - “I will redeem you.”
The fourth cup is called “the cup of Completion” - “I will take you to me for a people.” It is sometimes called “Elijah’s cup,” since the “completion” of God’s salvific plan must include His Messiah, and Elijah is the prophesied forerunner of the Messiah (Mal 4:5, 6). The titles of the four cups come from words and themes in Exo 6:6-8. Regarding "the poorest in Israel” it was written that those with means who are celebrating Passover “must not give them less than four cups of wine to drink" (Mishnah, Pesakhim 10.1). Why wine? Because it "makes glad the heart of man" (Psa 104:15; Tosefta, Pesakhim 10.4), and as such is suitable to commemorate freedom.
[17] Nevertheless, after up to 6 hours at the table, and at least four cups of wine, one tends to get sleepy (Mat 26:40-43). I know I do when participating in modern Passover Seders while in the U.S. and in Israel.
[18] This is EXTREMELY important! We must recognize that Jesus did not abolish the Law (Mat. 5:17-20) but obeyed it. Always. That is why not one of his challengers could ever convict him of sin (E.g. Joh 8:46). If he were going about the land of Israel disregarding the Law of Moses—as many Christians believe he was—anybody in his country could have proven that he was a sinner “because sin is a breaking of the Law” (1Joh 3:4 TEV). His frequent disputes with the Pharisees were matters of interpretation. Not practice. It is for this reason that his trial was unjust! According to the NT witness, Jesus was “born [and lived] … under the Law” (Gal 4:4 TEV), was tempted like all humans, “but did not sin” (Heb 4:15 TEV). Again, that means he obeyed the Law. My point is that we can safely assume that Jesus recounted the exodus from Egypt because it is a perpetual commandment for all descendants of Israel to do so on the Passover (Exo 12:24-27).


-Michael Millier

No comments:

Post a Comment